Finale Interruptus: Cold Cases - Case File #013: Lost in Space
Every television series begins with a promise…
Most do.
Some don’t.
Some endings are still missing.
These are their case files.
The Mission That Went Off Course
Dr. Zachary Smith has every reason to want the Robinsons’ mission to fail. He’s a saboteur, and he expects to be safely on the ground when his work takes effect. Then the Jupiter 2 lifts off with Smith still aboard. The extra weight throws the ship off course, and the man who meant to kill the passengers suddenly needs them alive. He wakes the people who have the best chance of saving him. They’re also the people he’ll have the hardest time explaining himself to.
The Robinsons and pilot Don West were supposed to go to Alpha Centauri. In the 1997 imagined by Irwin Allen’s Lost in Space, they were going to help establish a colony. John and Maureen were taking all three of their children with them. As far as the family knew when they boarded, they were making a good deal more than a long trip. They had agreed to start their lives over somewhere else. The first episode, “The Reluctant Stowaway,” takes away the certainty that they’ll ever reach the place they chose. MeTV’s episode guide follows the flight from launch to the meteor storm.
That leaves the series with two destinations it might eventually reach. Alpha Centauri is where the Robinsons meant to go. Earth is where they can tell somebody what happened. Either way, a safe landing would give them time to reckon with the man who put both destinations out of reach.
How Smith, Will, and the Robot Took Over
Jonathan Harris’s Smith is dangerous in the early episodes. He’s willing to let other people die to get what he wants, and the Robinsons are right to mistrust him. Over time Harris makes Smith’s fear as entertaining as his vanity. He can talk himself into an adventure, send someone else in ahead of him, and complain about the indignity of the rescue. A little of the saboteur is still there whenever Smith finds something he wants badly enough to start bargaining.
Will Robinson keeps giving him another chance. That generosity has consequences for the rest of the family, but it also gives the show a relationship it can go on testing. The Robot can spot danger and say so as plainly as anyone aboard. Will has the harder job of judging when Smith is genuinely frightened and when he’s hoping a boy will do something foolish on his behalf. In his Television Academy interview, Bill Mumy looks back on the relationship between Will and Smith, one of the enduring pairings of the series.
By the third season, Smith also has someone he can spend half an episode insulting and still count on when he needs help. The Robot’s patience with him varies. Its loyalty to Will gives the trio a balance they wouldn’t have if the boy were on his own. The three make enough trouble together to keep a weekly series going, but they also give a prospective ending something to settle. Getting the Robinsons home would raise the question of where Smith and the Robot belonged once everyone was free to go their own way.
The Boy Who Made It Home
In “Return to Earth,” Will gets a chance almost everyone aboard the Jupiter 2 would take. An alien transporter sends him home, where he can get a chemical needed to repair the ship’s purification system. He has a practical reason to be there and an urgent reason to get back. The people he encounters on Earth are working from a different set of facts. As MeTV’s synopsis points out, they believe the Robinsons died after the ship went off course. An unaccompanied boy announcing that he’s Will Robinson has a lot of convincing to do.
Mumy named “Return to Earth” as a favorite, and it gives him something worth playing. Will has already accomplished the thing the adults aboard have spent much of the series trying to do. He’s standing on Earth. The only way to make that trip count is to leave again. He can help his family by bringing back what they need, and that’s where he puts his effort.
For a series that keeps finding new worlds to send the Robinsons to, “Return to Earth” does something especially valuable with the world they left. It shows that Earth has gone on without them. If the ship ever made it back, a homecoming would mean more than an end to the shortage of food and spare parts. The Robinsons would finally get to tell their own story to a world that believed it already knew how it ended.
The Last Stop Was a Junkyard
On March 6, 1968, the Jupiter 2 came down on a planet that doubled as a junkyard. The crew’s food supply was in trouble, and Smith saw an opportunity to do business with the Junkman. The Robot had parts the Junkman could use. Smith offered them in exchange for food and eventually put the ship itself into the bargain. It’s a fitting last temptation for a man who has always been good at spotting the immediate benefit of a deal and leaving somebody else to work out what it will cost. The broadcast episode guide lists “Junkyard in Space” as the final installment.
Will follows in the Space Pod. The Junkman now has the Robot’s memory banks, and Will hopes enough of his friend is still there to influence what the Junkman does next. Smith sees parts that can be exchanged for supper. Will has spent enough time with the Robot to know what he’s asking the Junkman to give back. As the episode synopsis recounts, that knowledge gives him a chance to get through to the Junkman.
The Robinsons survive the encounter and get the chance to fly again. The episode does its weekly job. It gives the family trouble, lets Smith make it worse, and gives Will an opportunity to help put things right. Watching it as the last episode puts a different weight on that escape. The family gets its ship back, but viewers never get to see where it takes them.
The Fourth Season That Never Came
Bill Mumy and Angela Cartwright remembered expecting to return. In a joint interview about their years on the show, Mumy said the cast had been verbally told there would be a fourth season. They left the set expecting to see each other after the break. Nobody marked the end of production as the end of the series.
Mumy also recalled that CBS wanted Allen to turn in story treatments for another season and that Allen didn’t get them in. He acknowledged that there were competing explanations for the cancellation. The cast’s recollection tells us something more definite about the circumstances under which they finished the third season. As far as they knew, there would be another set of scripts and another day aboard the Jupiter 2.
The Television Academy records 83 broadcast episodes across three seasons. The last one happened to end at a point from which the series could easily have carried on. Another season could have postponed the Robinsons’ homecoming all over again. What the cancellation took away was the opportunity to decide when, and on whose terms, they finally got there.
CASE STATUS: OPEN
Mumy eventually wrote a homecoming himself. Lost in Space: The Epilogue remained unproduced as a drama, but the 2015 Blu-ray collection included a table read with Mumy, Cartwright, Marta Kristen and Mark Goddard among the participants. The boy who got back to Earth long enough to pick up something for a repair grew up to write a way back for everybody. Several of the people who had expected to see one another after that third-season break finally got to sit down together and read how the voyage might end. The Irwin Allen News Network lists the table read among the anniversary set’s extras.
That reading gives fans a homecoming imagined by someone who lived with the series from the beginning. The CBS episodes still leave the case open. Their last word on the Robinsons is that they got away from the junkyard and could keep flying. Somewhere back on Earth, there are still people who think the Jupiter 2 went down on its first flight. Will knows they’re wrong. He never gets to bring his family back and prove it.
